CPSO Says Every Rape Kit Is Submitted for Testing. State Audit Leaves 20 Kits Unexplained Across Southwest Louisiana.
When a Louisiana Legislative Auditor report revealed that hundreds of sexual assault evidence kits had not reached crime laboratories, the Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office pushed back against the suggestion that Southwest Louisiana shared the statewide problem.
The sheriff's office says its deputies submit every sexual assault kit they collect and that the Southwest Louisiana Regional Crime Lab processes kits submitted by agencies throughout its service area, unless a victim chooses not to proceed.
But figures cited from the same state audit leave one question unanswered.
Across five Southwest Louisiana parishes, law enforcement agencies collected 203 sexual assault kits during an 18-month period. Only 183 were recorded as submitted to the regional crime laboratory.
That is a difference of 20 kits.
The available figures do not identify which agencies collected those kits, why they were not submitted, or whether their status has since changed.
Those are important qualifications. The difference does not establish misconduct by CPSO or any particular agency.
But it does warrant an explanation.
What the statewide investigation found
The Louisiana Legislative Auditor examined the state's sexual assault kit tracking system, which is intended to follow evidence collected during forensic examinations.
The report, issued November 5, identified significant weaknesses in how evidence is submitted, tested and tracked.
Of 1,879 reported sexual assault kits collected across Louisiana from July 2024 through December 2025, auditors found that 337 had not been submitted to crime laboratories as of February 2026.
That represents approximately 18% of the reported kits examined.
The audit also identified problems with submission deadlines and the accuracy of information available to victims trying to track their evidence.
Louisiana law generally requires law enforcement agencies to retrieve reported sexual assault kits from medical providers within 72 hours and submit them to a crime laboratory within 30 days.
However, the law does not explicitly require laboratories to test every reported kit they receive.
That gap has left different laboratories using different procedures when investigators or prosecutors decide not to pursue a case.
CPSO disputes the implication that the statewide findings reflect local practices
Following publication of the audit, the Calcasieu Parish Sheriff's Office issued a statement reported by KPLC.
CPSO emphasized that it operates the Southwest Louisiana Regional Crime Lab, which serves law enforcement agencies in Calcasieu, Allen, Beauregard, Cameron and Jefferson Davis parishes.
The department said its laboratory personnel process submitted sexual assault kits unless a victim chooses not to move forward.
Sheriff's office spokesperson Kayla Vincent also told KPLC that CPSO deputies submit every kit they collect.
Those statements are significant.
They indicate that CPSO maintains procedures intended to prevent the kinds of failures identified in the statewide report.
But they address two different responsibilities.
One is whether an agency submits evidence to a laboratory.
The other is whether a laboratory processes evidence after receiving it.
A laboratory cannot test evidence that never arrives.
And a sheriff's office cannot necessarily account for collection and submission practices at every other law enforcement agency within the laboratory's service area.
The 20-kit question
According to the regional figures reported by KPLC, agencies across the five-parish region collected 203 sexual assault kits during the audit period.
Of those, 183 were submitted to the Southwest Louisiana Regional Crime Lab.
The difference represents approximately 9.9% of the regional collection total.
That does not mean 20 kits were lost, destroyed or improperly withheld.
Some may have been retained under circumstances not established in the published figures. Others may have been submitted after the period examined, or their handling may require clarification from tracking records.
The available reporting does not resolve those possibilities.
It also does not identify which law enforcement agencies were responsible for the unsubmitted kits.
The appropriate question is not whether CPSO can account for every kit collected throughout Southwest Louisiana. It is whether the responsible agencies and the statewide tracking system can account for each of the 20 kits reflected in the regional difference.
A complete explanation would identify each kit's current status, the agency responsible for its custody, the reason it was not recorded as submitted and whether the required deadlines were met.
Those answers could establish that the difference was administrative, procedural or something requiring corrective action.
Without them, the regional numbers remain unresolved.
Testing a kit is not the same as submitting it
This is where the statewide findings become especially important.
The Legislative Auditor found that Louisiana's crime laboratories do not all apply the same standards when deciding whether to test sexual assault evidence.
According to the audit, one laboratory reported testing all kits submitted by law enforcement.
Five others indicated they might decline testing when law enforcement or prosecutors reported that an investigation would not proceed.
Such decisions create concerns about evidence that could potentially connect separate offenses.
DNA evidence collected during one investigation may produce leads relevant to another.
A case that does not result in prosecution today may still contain evidence that becomes important later.
The auditor also identified problems involving communication and follow-up after potential DNA matches through the FBI's Combined DNA Index System, commonly known as CODIS.
Those problems illustrate why evidence collection, submission, analysis and investigative follow-up must be evaluated separately.
Louisiana has a tracking system. The audit says it needs stronger oversight.
Louisiana established its statewide sexual assault kit tracking system in 2023, with mandatory participation beginning July 1, 2024.
The system is intended to let survivors anonymously monitor the status of their evidence while providing a record of transfers among medical providers, law enforcement agencies and forensic laboratories.
But the Legislative Auditor found that tracking information was not always complete or accurate.
Statewide, at least 560 of 2,138 kits collected during the reviewed period missed a required pickup or laboratory-submission deadline.
The report also identified limitations in oversight and the absence of statutory penalties for certain failures to comply with tracking requirements.
The Louisiana State Police, which administers the system, agreed to pursue corrective improvements.
Additional legislation has already addressed aspects of tracking unresolved DNA database matches, with further implementation requirements taking effect in 2027.
What Southwest Louisiana deserves to know
CPSO's public statement deserves to be reported accurately.
The sheriff's office maintains that its deputies submit every kit collected and that its regional laboratory processes submitted evidence, subject to the stated victim-related exception.
The available state figures do not disprove those claims.
But neither does the statement explain the difference between the 203 kits collected regionally and the 183 submitted to the regional laboratory.
The outstanding questions are straightforward:
- Which agencies collected the 20 kits not reflected in the regional laboratory submissions?
- Were any of those kits subsequently submitted or tested?
- Were any classified as unreported, withdrawn or otherwise ineligible for testing?
- Did any agency miss Louisiana's statutory evidence-submission deadlines?
- What procedures ensure victims receive accurate information about the status of their evidence?
These questions should be answered through the statewide tracking system and the records of the agencies responsible for handling the evidence.
The purpose is not to assign responsibility without evidence.
It is to establish whether every kit can be accounted for.
For someone who has undergone a forensic examination after reporting a sexual assault, that accountability matters considerably more than a reassuring statement.
The public deserves to know that evidence has been properly handled. Survivors deserve to know where their evidence is.
And when a state audit identifies an unexplained difference involving 20 kits in Southwest Louisiana, requesting those answers is reasonable.
Sources
- Louisiana Legislative Auditor, Sexual Assault Kit Tracking System and Outstanding CODIS Hits, issued November 5, 2026 — Control No. 40250022.
- KPLC: All rape kits submitted to Calcasieu crime lab tested, officials say — November 10 reporting and CPSO statement.
- Louisiana Illuminator: Almost 20% of rape kits in Louisiana aren't tested, audit finds — November 10, 2026.
- Louisiana Revised Statutes 15:624.1, Sexual Assault Collection Kit Tracking
- Louisiana State Police Sexual Assault Kit Tracking Unit
- 337.NEWS Public Records Repository — research repository; the November audit has not been independently confirmed as archived.
Photo: Supreme Court building with classical columns. Photo by Malcolm Hill, via Pexels.
Member discussion
337.NEWS discussion
Join the conversation.
Sign up to comment on this story and follow the local reporting behind it.